Lily Allen, Pink Floyd, Spurgeon, Slingshots, Hebrews and Quintuple Negatives

One of my favourite lines from Lily Allen’s last album* comes from the tongue-in-track track Silver Spoon where she sings:

Can’t say that life isn’t easy
Double negative: can’t nothing please me?

Double negatives are strange little things. In many languages they cancel each other out and resolve to a positive, sometimes with deliberately ironic results, as in the example above, or in the Pink Floyd lyric:

We don’t need no education.

In other languages, multiple negatives have the opposite effect; each one building upon and intensifying the others.

In Hebrews 13:5 we find not one, not two, not even three, but five negatives woven into one punchy little promise:

I will never leave you nor forsake you.

This quote, probably from Joshua 1:5, was a much needed reassurance to believers who were undergoing suffering, imprisonment and the temptation to renounce their faith (e.g. 10:32-34; 13:3). The combination of a double negative (οὐ μή) and a triple negative (οὐδʼ οὐ μή) makes for a pretty emphatic statement about the faithfulness of God in the midst of their trials.

Spurgeon puts it like this in his aptly-named sermon Never! Never! Never! Never! Never!
I have no doubt you are aware that our translation does not convey the whole force of the original, and that it would hardly be possible in English to give the full weight of the Greek. We might render it, “He hath said, I will never, never leave thee; I will never, never, never forsake thee;” for, though that would be not a literal, but rather a free rendering, yet, as there are five negatives in the Greek, we do not know how to give their force in any other way. Two negatives nullify each other in our language; but here, in the Greek, they intensify the meaning following one after another, as I suppose David’s five stones out of the brook would have done if the first had not been enough to make the giant reel.
Five nevers. As if one wasn’t enough. A sling-shot-stone into the forehead of a Goliath-sized fear. I’m not sure the author of Hebrews could have put it much stronger if he’d tried.
Fionda Balearica tutorial -17 by D'ario Pedruzzi
Fionda Balearica tutorial -17 by D’ario Pedruzzi

* Warning for those with sensitive ears – the album is well-laden with profanity!

3 Comments Add yours

  1. Judith Barnett says:

    Hey – I know this post was back in Jan but I’ve come back to it so many times. It spoke to me then and it still does. God is using it in my life (& I’m sure in others.) Please be encouraged.


    1. liamthatcher says:

      Thanks Judith, glad to hear that!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s